The Ongoing Trade War: Analyzing China's Response, the US Strategy, and Global Implications

(Summary of Scott Galloway's conversation with Alice Han)

The trade war between the United States and China has been a focal point of international economic discussions for years. While the headlines are often filled with aggressive tariffs and political posturing, the fundamental dynamics at play are far more intricate. The trade conflict between these two global giants has far-reaching implications for their economies and the rest of the world.

In this post, we will delve into the current state of play from China's perspective, the outcome of the trade war, the ongoing US-China talks, and how global trade patterns are shifting. We’ll also explore which countries are coming out ahead and where the future of US-China relations might be heading.

1. Current Sentiment in China Regarding the Trade War and Tariffs

General Sentiment in China

In a recent visit to China, Alice Han, an economist and expert on the Chinese political economy, noted a remarkable resolve among government officials and citizens. Despite tariffs ranging from 30% to 145%, the sentiment was far from panic. Instead, there was a firm commitment to defending China's economic interests. This echoes Cold War rhetoric of resisting foreign pressures and asserting independence. Chinese officials are confident they can absorb the shock from these tariffs due to their fiscal capacity and a well-established strategy of rerouting trade through third-party countries to avoid US tariffs.

Private Sector Sentiment

The private sector, particularly the tech sector, is showing signs of optimism. Tech executives are more positive about future growth, despite the burdens of tariffs, compared to the outlook in previous years. This confidence is driven by China's ability to adapt, innovate, and expand in global markets.

US vs. China Sentiment

China remains resolute compared to the US, where there is a significant degree of skepticism about the trade war's effectiveness. The US has been grappling with its own economic concerns, with many feeling disillusioned about the long-term impacts of the tariffs on businesses and consumers.

2. The Outcome of the Trade War

Trump’s Response

President Trump’s strategy initially involved imposing hefty tariffs on Chinese goods. However, he was ultimately forced to back down due to pressure from business leaders and the potential harm to his base—empty shelves and rising prices were unfavorable for US consumers. In this "game of chicken," China was able to assert dominance through escalation and political will, forcing the US to step back.

Tariff Reductions

• US Tariffs: Reduced from 145% to 30%.

• China’s Tariffs were reduced from 125% to 10%. These reductions are part of an ongoing negotiation lasting 90 days, but they signify a notable shift in the trade relationship.

3. The Goal of US-China Talks

What the US Wants

The US’s primary goal is to negotiate a “big, beautiful deal,” similar to the one Nixon orchestrated when he visited China in the 1980s. The Trump administration wants to address the trade imbalance, implement sector-specific tariffs (particularly on technologies like AI and semiconductors), and secure stronger market access for US businesses in China. Another critical point of discussion is fentanyl, with the US pushing for China to crack down on the production of fentanyl precursors.

What China Wants

For China, the primary goal is supply chain self-sufficiency, particularly in critical sectors like semiconductors. China is determined to reduce its dependence on the US and other external forces for its economic stability and to manage geopolitical risks. Additionally, China is focused on maintaining economic growth and navigating the ongoing tensions surrounding Taiwan.

Rebalancing Trade

While both parties agree on the need to rebalance trade, significant hurdles remain. China is not keen on sweeping changes to its economic structure, as its growth model still relies heavily on manufacturing and exports. Conversely, the US is pushing for market reciprocity and reductions in the trade deficit.

4. China’s Economic Structure and Goals

Structural Challenges

China is currently grappling with a structural slowdown in its economy. Private consumption remains weak, accounting for only 40% of GDP, compared to 70% in the US. This imbalance makes it difficult for China to boost domestic demand, especially given the over-reliance on exports and manufacturing.

Policy Direction

Despite these challenges, China’s leadership recognizes that the country needs to shift its economic model towards more sustainable growth. This includes increasing domestic consumption and reducing overcapacity in certain industries. However, political reluctance to fully commit to these changes means China is trying to balance short-term economic growth and long-term rebalancing.

Supply Chain Resilience

China focuses on supply chain resilience to secure its position in global markets. It prioritizes investing in self-sufficiency in critical sectors like semiconductors and AI. This is particularly important as global tensions rise and tariffs threaten to disrupt trade.

5. China’s Relationship with the US: Economic Shifts and Rebalancing

Shifting Trade Patterns

To circumvent US tariffs, China has been actively rerouting its trade through third-party countries, particularly Southeast Asia and Latin America. The US share of China’s exports has decreased from 24% to 17%, but interestingly, China’s trade surplus with the US has grown. This shift, known as “tariff washing,” allows China to bypass US restrictions by using intermediary countries to conduct trade.

Geopolitical and Economic Alliances

China is increasingly turning to Latin America and Europe as key trade partners. With growing relationships in countries like Brazil and Argentina, China is diversifying its economic ties away from the US. Additionally, Europe is becoming more strategically autonomous, balancing trade with the US and China while reducing trade barriers, particularly in the electric vehicle (EV) sector.

6. Winners and Losers from the Trade War

Big Winners

• Southeast Asia: Countries like India, Vietnam, Indonesia, and Malaysia benefit from companies seeking alternatives to Chinese manufacturing.

• Latin America: Brazil is a major beneficiary, particularly in agriculture, as China shifts away from US suppliers.

• Europe: Europe is positioning itself to extract key economic concessions from China, particularly in the technology and EV sectors.

China’s Divestment from the US

China’s ongoing divestment from the US continues to reshape global trade dynamics. As the percentage of Chinese exports to the US continues shrinking, China seeks to build stronger relationships with alternative trading partners.

7. Future Outlook: China vs. US

“Chimerica” - A New Era of Cooperation

Alice Han suggests the possibility of a future relationship where China and the US continue to reinforce each other in a “Chimerica” relationship. Despite the tensions, both countries are integral to each other’s economic success, particularly in sectors like tech manufacturing and global supply chains.

US Resilience

The US remains a strong, consumer-driven economy, and its ability to innovate and adapt provides a long-term advantage. Despite political and economic challenges, the US continues to hold significant global influence, with its knowledge economy, immigration policies, and technological innovations driving future growth.

China’s Strength in Manufacturing

China is poised to continue its dominance in tech manufacturing, with companies like BYD leading the change. The country’s investments in AI, semiconductors, and other emerging technologies place it in a strong position for global competition.

Geopolitical Tensions

While the geopolitical landscape remains fraught with challenges, China and the US are deeply intertwined in the global economy. The outcome of their trade relationship will likely shape the world’s economic future for decades.

Conclusion

The US-China trade war is far from over, but the shifting global dynamics offer a nuanced view of the future. While both countries continue to battle over tariffs, their economic futures are intertwined. With China shifting its focus toward supply chain resilience and the US seeking market reciprocity, the next chapter in their relationship may not be a “divorce” as some have feared, but rather a complex rebalancing. As we look toward the future, the global trade landscape will be shaped by these two superpowers and the growing influence of emerging markets and strategic regional alliances.

In the end, the world may see the emergence of a more interconnected global economy that navigates the complexities of US-China relations while finding new avenues for cooperation and growth.

Watch our latest video about this topic: